View Single Post
Old 16th August 2013, 00:46   #5  |  Link
ganymede
Registered User
 
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Paris
Posts: 52
@raffriff42 and Warperus : thank you for your very informative answers.
Quote:
BT.601 color matrix must be used to convert YUV data back to RGB
That makes sense, but is surprising because these Canon MOV files are HD.

As practical consequences, when editing this kind of footage, am I safe to assume that :
  • if I don't resize the video stream, I should convert color matrix to BT.709 (eg. with avisynth ColorMatrix or vapoursynth fmtconv) to ensure that it will be displayed correctly on most players ?
  • but in case I downsize from HD to SD, I don't have to apply any color matrix filter, and can just flag the edited stream as BT.601 ?
There is indeed a possibility that these files are incorrectly flagged, as raffriff42 suggests, but it would be a surprizing mistake from Canon, and I'm under the impression that colors were more "right" on my calibrated monitor when displayed as a BT.601 YUV stream than as a BT.709 one... Of course, it's not exact science
ganymede is offline   Reply With Quote